Tuesday, January 27, 2009

Food Stamps and Other Badges of Shame

So I'm standing in the Park Slope Food Co-op, having just finished unloading my groceries out of the cart and the woman doing check-out says, "Do you know how to do EBT on the computer? Do I just push 'total'? What do you usually do?"

I shake my head, "Sorry, this is my first time using this card."

She smiles, "This is my first time too." She asks the man behind her, but he seems a little unsure so then she hollers over to the check-out person behind me, "Hey! Do you know how to process food stamps?" Only to me it sounds like "LOOK OVER HERE AT THIS LAYABOUT BITCH WHO'S TOO LAZY TO GET A JOB AND IS USING OUR HARD EARNED TAX DOLLARS TO BUY HER ORGANIC APPLES!!!" The check-out person is nice enough, I'm sure she doesn't mean to call attention to me. But she's not the first that afternoon to advertise my situation across the crowded co-op floor. She's the second. The first was the cashier, when I tried out my card with one item to make sure it worked. The cashier said "Food Stamps? You're paying with food stamps?" Only it sounded more like, "FOOD STAMPS? FUCKING WELFARE MOM." Then a third person, another cashier, also asked more than once, in a loud voice, if I was paying with food stamps. I don't know if this is due to the insensitivity of these three workers, the noise in the co-op, if they were truly judging me, or if this has to do with the co-op's new debit card system, but it sucks.

At this co-op, everyone who shops there is required to work there for three hours every four weeks. So although some people are more professional than others, this isn't their day job by any means. When I used to do check-out, before the new debit card system, I was merely required to ask of every shopper, "Are you paying with cash or EBT?" EBT, which stands for "Electronic Benefit Transfer" didn't sound so demeaning. It just sounded like another way of paying. And actually, Food Stamps are no longer called that. According to the Department of Agriculture, "As of Oct. 1, 2008, Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) is the new name for the federal Food Stamp Program." This afternoon's shopping experience made me want to do my grocery shopping at our local supermarket instead, where the food is more expensive and not nearly as healthy, there when people pull out their EBT cards, no one bats an eyelash.

Without going into detail about our particular situation, all I can say is that Big Joe works very hard, lately seven days a week, and I am looking for a job. I may not be working at a jobby job but I only sleep six hours a night, and only one of the hours that I'm awake is spent idly - reading the newspapers on the internet. Although we've always been frugal, in the past four months we've gone beyond our usual thriftiness. We haven't gone to movies, or bought books, or gone out to dinner. We stopped buying treats like the occasional cookie or scone. We never hire babysitters. We haven't bought new clothes in a very long time. We don't go on vacation, or spend money on alcohol or cigarettes or drugs of any kind. Big Joe rides his bike everywhere so we just spend money on a metrocard for me. We're not working the system. If I could find suitable employment, I would be working. And yet I feel so very ashamed. No, ASHAMED. Capital letters. I mean I've lived here for 15 years, worked, paid taxes. Been an upstanding citizen even when I technically wasn't. But when I Googled "When will I get my EBT card?" after we waited and waited and it failed to arrive in the mail; I found the answer on Yahoo Answers, and below was a comment with many expletives that went something along the lines of, "Why don't you get a job and stop spreading your legs for every man, and popping out babies?"

When I was a teenager I volunteered at a Food Bank in Vancouver, and the people who volunteered with me were upset that I was volunteering there but didn't need a bag of groceries myself. Because they all did. And volunteering there was how they dealt with their feelings of shame. I didn't understand that then, and was mystified by their hostility, but it all became quite clear this afternoon.

I've judged people paying with EBT cards at Food Dimensions. Judging their bottles of soda and chips and boxes of Entenmann's cakes. And when I worked as a check out worker at the co-op I've looked at the person paying with an EBT card and thought, "They don't look like they need food stamps." So now I'm on the other side. And that's good. I'm learning to have even more empathy. Because you just never know what life's going to hand you. One day you're having cocktails, shopping at designer sample sales and taking cabs (not that I've done that in at least ten years) and the next you're collecting food stamps.

18 comments:

Fabulous Financials said...

YOU...a gentrifier...on foodstamps? Hmm...this makes your entire blog ironic - almost comical. No matter how you slice and dice the who, what, when, where, how OR why - you're STILL on welfare.

If the experience teaches you empathy, then I guess it's a good thing. Please keep that in mind as you continue to observe the lifelong, HARD WORKING, residents of BedStuy.

Good luck on your job search.

Bed-Stuy Banana said...

Yes, it is ironic, that my family, considered evil gentrifiers with money to burn, when all the time we've lived here, we've just gotten by. That just proves the racism, and bigotry of some of the people who live here and judge us based on our colour. I guess you're learning something too. Only it doesn't appear to be empathy.

Congratulations on your financial success. Guess what, we work hard too, we just haven't been quite as lucky as you.

Sister Toldja said...

FF-There is somewhat of an irony, but it's not as you make it sound. I think it's ironic that a struggling family that is on food stamps would make the neighborhood "more appealing" to some potential residents and business owners because of the color of their skin, where as long term or Black residents who may not be recieveing benefits are considered undesireable.

BSB- I think it's great that you are speaking about your situation. People have these stereotypes about people who recieve food stamps: single Black "Welfare queens", uneducated immigrants, "poor White trash", when in reality, all sorts of people go through troubling financial times. Government aid is SUPPOSED to help us when we need it! I hate the stigma attached to food stamps. While it's not fun to have to advertise to strangers that you aren't working or earning enough, shit happens! I was on food stamps for a while in college and for some time when I looked for my post-college job. I've recieved unemployent before...I was just happy to have them!!! I've had friends that were too high on their horses to recieve either, despite needing them. But I bet the current economic crisis is making a lot of people change their stances.

vettievette said...

ST and BSB - Funny, I was JUST having that convo this morning w/ a good friend of mine who lives in Pittsburgh, PA. This socioeconomic mucky mess we're in is shaking everything up and I'm hoping that people are using this as an opportunity to re-think our own personal situations and what is happening in the community. BSB - you're doing whatever you can to take care of you and yours. As you know - I always have my ear to the ground on creative opportunities and jobs...I'll let you know of anything that comes my way. :)

FF - ugh. K.I.M.

Jimmy Legs said...

thanks for writing this, most people would bee too chicken to bring up such subjects in a public forum (i don't see the irony here aside from other people's misapprehension of your writing). is it difficult to qualify for EBT? i don't think it's as simple as most detractors think. good luck with the job search; it is tough out there.

Bed-Stuy Banana said...

ST, thank you for your thoughtful and kind comments. They're especially appreciated considering your stance on gentrifiers. Also, thank you for sharing your experience. You're right, there are racist and classist stereotypes about the kind of person who receives food stamps.

JL + VV, I also think it's good for other people to hear about my experience. To break down some of the misconceptions. And in some ways it is easy to get food stamps - they say that you don't need a mailing address (but I'm not sure how true that is), but in many ways it's impossible. The paperwork is horrendous. Lord help you if English is your second language, or if you're illiterate, or if you can't take the time off work to wait all day in a waiting room for your interview. Because, yes, there were many people in that waiting room who were employed but their salaries just weren't enough to support their families in this city.

BestViewInBrooklyn said...

I can't blame the cashiers for having to ask. It's a madhouse there, and the few times I was a check-out person, I was mightily confused. I haven't been there in so long that I have no idea what the "new" system is like. Their method of obtaining the information, however, is insensitive. I think that someone who has never had to accept assistance from the government or any other organization doesn't understand the complex emotions that go along with it. I'll bet that they were just clueless and not giving you the stink-eye.

I'm sure you know about this, but just in case...you can use EBT at farmers and green markets in NY. Check it out on their website. A google search will bring it up as well.

911NewYorker said...

BSB,ST- EBT(food stamps)were to be used for a short period of time...until you got back on your feet again! weren't meant to be a life-time right of passage.

ST-the so-called long time residents lie, vs so-called gentrifiers; the biggest myth going on. . BSB doesn't ever need to put on knee pads for relocating to Bed-Stuy.

Traci said...

I'm a newish coop member myself, but I'm pretty sure there's a diversity/equality committee. Seems like this would be something worth bringing to their attention. I'm sure having shopping squad leaders or whoever oversees the cashiers give a one minute demo at the start of each shift on processing EBT is something worthwhile, with the economy the way it is.

Also - I think the people who sit at the registers by the door are staff (or at least better trained members), maybe just telling the checkout worker that you're paying cash and then giving those other folks the EBT is a good plan. Assuming they're more in the know...

Hebrew School said...

Rude and insensitive people at the Park Slope food coop? Now I've heard everything.
That's right, people who are having trouble affording decent, healthy food: We're not going to make you work for your food once, but twice. And we'll shame you for it either way.
Fuck that place. BVIB's right-- check out the greenmarkets.

Sister Toldja said...

911NewYorker- Neither of us were suggesting that food stams were a right of passage. But given the state of the economy, a lot more people may find theirselves making that call. I suppose you are blessed not to have that problem. Good for you. You sound rather pompous in both your comments. No one told BSB to bow down, and at least she's open to understanding why people are uncomfortable with gentrification. I take it you are more of the "knock em out of my way so I can get this luxury condo" sort who has no regard for anyone. Swell!

bulletthesky said...

great post (love the blog btw =) )

Pistols And Popcorn said...

Hey Bed Stuy!

Listen, I was on Food Stamps while in college, and I've been collecting unemployment for a while now. Actually, I just ran through the end of my benefits, and am grateful that you reminded me about food stamps. Can I take assistance, unashamed, to feed my family while the economy gets out of this clusterfuck that it's in?

Yes I Can!

Well written - as always.

Miss Heather said...

The moral of the story here is damned if you and damned if you don't. If BSB was not on public assistance and stated that she liked living in a predominantly black neighborhood she would be accused of "slumming" and pricing out the "hard working" residents of Bedford Stuyvesant. But she is on public assistance and therefore can be condemned for being lazy, lacking empathy, etc.

FF (as "progressive" as he/she fancies him/herself) is spouting rhetoric borne the Victorian era: poverty is an indication of a lack of moral character, e.g.; if there was nothing wrong with BSB (READ: if she worked hard enough) she would not be unemployed (the stereotypes of which Sister Toldja writes). Nothing could be further from the truth.

I know a lot of people (black, white, Hispanic and otherwise) who are out of work right for no fault of their own.

I also know a lot of people who work 2-3 jobs and still need help. "HARD WORK" doesn't have a damned thing to do with it.

The popular misconception about my community's local soup kitchen is it only serves derelicts, drunks and bums. In other words: those who are unemployed or "unemployable" by choice. Nothing could be further from the truth: a great many senior citizens on fixed incomes can no longer afford to pay rent and purchase groceries. They're seeing a lot more families with children nowadays. Perhaps FF would like to swing by and give these "slackers" a lecture on social responsibility?

If FF wants to lay the blame on someone for this he/she should look in the mirror. It's the voting patterns people like him/her have (in all probability) espoused for the last 8+ years that have put this country in the situation it now finds itself.

"Food Stamps" and other forms of public assistance were put in place for a reason. There should be no shame in receiving them. That's why we, as citizens, pay taxes.

imee said...

I don't think anybody should be ashamed of using food stamps or any other sort of welfare at all. After all, it's taxpayer money--we have all the right if ever we qualify. The only people who should be ashamed are those who can clearly still live within their means even without welfare, and those who buy junk food with their food stamps (food mainly is for nutrition, not entertainment).

-Imee

Ray Johnson said...

I have often looked at the people with expertly coiffed hair using such benefits on the lines here in Sheepshead Bay, wearing their leather, 3 1/2" high-heel boots, designer duds and furs, unable to run their card through the machine, because their acrylic nails got in the way and I've thought about the system loopholes. They stand proud to buy caviar and smoked fish, then carry their luxuries to a just-waxed Infiniti and I too, have often wondered about the how the system appears to be abused.

But, my attention would immediately get diverted by my own situation, as I told the clerk a lie about how I somehow had "forgotten enough cash" and so I needed to put back the bread, eggs, milk, and broccoli.

Focus on doing the right thing and your goal and not on the abusers.

Just keep up the good work and remember your conscientiousness is appreciated. Things will get better.

Rin said...

Why did you pay taxes? You put into a system that sets aside money for those less fortunate or going through rough patches. You carried someone else for a long time when you paid taxes. Put aside your pride and use your EBT card with a smile. Our system rewards the mega rich and leaves the scraps for the working wagers or out of work to scramble over (and why low income people fight over who gets what all the time just like in this blog commentary). If we had a tax system that was reasonably fair then a woman like you struggling to find work, with a baby, could stay home without worry while her man worked hard.

As for the blacks who say "our neighborhood". You're acting just like the old time white people who resented a massive influx of southern baptist blacks into Bed. Don't you know the history of "your" place? Nearly all of it was white until the 1950s. For hundreds of years it was predominately white. If you want to get technical about it, you're still new. "Your" neighborhood was someone else's before your parents or grandparents showed up. Now it's your turn and you don't like it, do you? You're all fools who argue with each other over petty issues because if you embraced each other you'd all live like superstars on easy street.

D W JazzLover said...

This reminds me of something that happened years ago and it is still here!(Judgments)
My Mother had worked hard from the time she was 12 years old when her parents died a month apart and she did it very sucessfully,until I was 19 and working my way through University.
The next year she had a brain bleed and had brain surgery. At this time with all the medical bills she needed assistance as it was called then.
When I took her down to apply my dear Mother was treated as dirt....it was truly very bad..
I almost quit school to take care of her but instead took a third job and slept less than 3 hours a day to make sure she would never have to go to that place and face that humiliating experience ever again. and she didn't ever have too.
Yes there are people who abuse the system, but there are so many more who don't! Keep your head held high BSB.
I do like your blog..